Doing the
Charlie Brown Christmas made me think of other Christmas movies. I think I collected all the best Christmas movies and placed them somewhere on my
Huge List of Movies Every Child Should See. It was surprising how large a percentage of the appropriate-for-a-five-year-old movies were Christmas ones.
The top rated one,
How the Grinch stole Christmas, is an all-time favorite for me. There are some strange people who like the Jim Carey version, but I'm too large a fan of the traditional cartoon to care for that movie.
Rudolph and
Santa Claus is Comin' to Town are great claymation films.
Frosty the Snowman is a brilliant story too! And all of these have good morals in each of their stories.
I included
Yes Virginia on the movie list, another Christmas film, but it's not really a classic in the same way that all the rest of these are. I'm sort of ambivalent about whether it should even be on that 'must see' list, in fact. It's cute, to be sure, and certainly appropriate for a very young audience, but it doesn't strike me as something that, if you didn't see it, you'd be missing out on much. Also the message is one about how Santa is real - that your belief in that is important. That's not something I will be encouraging our children to believe, so it seems a bit counter-productive. to include.
For an older audience, I have
Miracle on 34th Street, It's a Wonderful Life, Muppet's Christmas Carol, Nightmare Before Christmas, The Christmas Story, and
Scrooged.
None of these, however, talk about the real meaning behind Christmas. It is a celebration of Jesus' brith and, sadly, there are not many hints of that in any of these films. With that in mind, I don't think we'll watch any of these on Christmas day. I intend to focus more on the idea of it being Jesus' birthday, including a birthday cake and discussion about Jesus' life and His continuing work in us. We'll see how this all plays out.
Anyway, the story behind
It's a Wonderful Life is quite fascinating. It only really became a hit
because it was a flop in its initial release. It was pretty much given to the networks to play for free every year, so that's what they did. In this case, familiarity didn't breed contempt, but delight in the eyes of the public. They grew to love it, so it became a classic in the end. Another interesting tidbit is that the watchdog groups overseeing movies of that time decreed that all villains meet their just ends, but in this movie, the 'evil banker' slips through without any consequence to his mean character. The film makers managed to sneak that past the censors somehow...
I can't say I'm a huge fan of the muppets, but
A Muppet Christmas Carol is genuinely fun! It's probably my favorite version of the Charles Dickens classic. Another version, starting Jim Carey (that's the second time he's been mentioned here, isn't it?) is probably truer to the book, but it isn't as heart-warming or sweet.
Nightmare Before Christmas is weird. I could just leave it at that, because that statement seems to summarize the movie fairly well. That and creepy. All of Tim Burton's stuff is weird and creepy, really. But, despite the disturbing atmosphere, the story is actually pretty good and it is so darn original that I can't help but be impressed with it despite myself. In the end though, this may be more of a Halloween movie than a Christmas one.
The second black-and-white film on the list,
Miracle on 34th Street is a film I've only seen a few times and so don't know it well enough to say too much about it. It was a cute movie though, one that I think would make for an enjoyable Christmas-time treat.
The movie about the BB-gun! I'm rather bemused by how many people absolutely love this movie. I must be missing the greatness here because I rather dislike it. I don't know why.
The Christmas Story is culturally relevant (and I think my husband likes it), so we'll watch it.
The second version of Dicken's classic,
Scrooged, is the last of the Christmas movies on my list...at least I think it is. Perhaps there will be more added later. I'm sure Hollywood is not done making movies on that popular holiday. In fact, there are a slew of other movies out there that other people would probably be
appalled that I've left off my lists. Like
Elf or
The Santa Clause. Most of those movies are pretty stupid comedies though which I strongly detest, so they didn't make my movie list.
And Now I'm finished rambling.